In the Fall 2017 ENGL 431: Octavia Butler class I took with Dr. Beth, we discussed the implications behind sight and seeing. We talked about how sight ties in very closely with the theme of consent; looking at something or someone without explicit consent, such as looking at another person’s diary, is wrong. We also discussed how sight can determine power dynamics; there is a power dynamic at play in situations where the one being seen is unable to prevent others from seeing them. I’m seeing similarities between what I learned back then and the concepts we’ve discussed in class so far.Continue reading “Power of Sight”
Because I’m a small picture type of person, I tend to break statements, concepts, or facts down in an effort to better understand them. Thus, when I read the course epigraph, I broke it down into 2 parts: “job is to notice” and “to notice that you can notice.” Interestingly enough, after analyzing each part and trying to make connections to our readings or discussions, I found that the interpretation of the epigraph changes depending on which text you associate with it.Continue reading “More Than Just Myself”
Just to continue the discussion about gender pronouns (kinda):
Back when I was looking for evidence for my blog post about empathy, I stumbled across two sections.
“(Nikanj) had no same-sex children, and that was a real deprivation” (428).
“(Dichaan) lay down again to comfort Nikanj and was not surprised to find that the ooloi needed comfort….It was to lose a year of Akin’s childhood. In its home with its large family all around, it felt alone and tired” (429).
When I read it, or, more accurately, reread it, I immediately thought Oh.
Jodas tells us that the term “ooloi” is “complex” and not fully translatable into English (326). He gives us some of the meanings: “treasured stranger,” “bridge,” “life trader,” “weaver,” “magnet” (326).
The term that caught my attention was “bridge.” Continue reading ““Bridge” & Empathy”
Jdahya tells Lilith humans have two “incompatible characteristics” (38). The first is “intelligence” and the second is “hierarchy” (39). The Oankali believe that the second characteristic is a “problem” and detrimental to the human race. Jdahya also tells Lilith: “(The Oankali) are not hierarchical” (41).
But are they really not?
Two classes back or so, we discussed what bothered us about Dawn. What bothered me about Dawn was Nikanj.
I initially liked Nikanj. I felt that, out of the other Oankali, Nikanj respected Lilith as a human being the most. When speaking of altering Lilith’s brain chemistry to help her speak the Onankali language, Nikanj states that it thinks “surprising people” is wrong because it’s like, “Treating (people) as though they aren’t people, as though they aren’t intelligent” (79). Nikanj was ordered by Kahguyaht to “surprise” Lilith—to change her brain chemistry without her consent. The fact that Nikanj realizes this is wrong and decides to tell Lilith made me very happy. I feel that Nikanj, by deciding to tell Lilith, displays a level of respect for her as an individual and treats her as another being as opposed to a research subject. Another instance of this is the conversation about Lilith’s injuries from Paul Tidus: Nikanj questions whether Lilith “need(ed)” to be told information concerning her, and promises to remember that she does need and want to be told (100). Nikanj, through words and gestures, shows that it believes Lilith’s opinion, her consent, is important. I loved that.
Then, of course, the ending ruined everything.
- “Prisoner(s) of War”
- The title of the second section
As I was reading Clay’s Ark, I wondered how much control the infected individuals had over themselves. Blake, in his analysis of the organism in Meda, feels that the organism, “Had left her no longer human” (498). This contrasts with Eli who continues to eat cooked food because he feels it’s a “human thing” he can cling on (515). Blake believes the organism takes away one’s entire humanity; Eli believes he still has some control/self autonomy.